Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Select Review

Updated September 20, 2024 By Richard Thomas Rating: B+ The single barrel whiskey concept, in America at least, began with the introduction of Blanton’s in 1984 by the legendary Master Distiller Elmer T. Lee. Back then, however, that Frankfort, Kentucky distillery was known as the George T. Stagg Distillery. It wouldn’t be renamed Buffalo Trace …

Updated September 20, 2024

By Richard Thomas

Rating: B+

The single barrel whiskey concept, in America at least, began with the introduction of Blanton’s in 1984 by the legendary Master Distiller Elmer T. Lee. Back then, however, that Frankfort, Kentucky distillery was known as the George T. Stagg Distillery. It wouldn’t be renamed Buffalo Trace until 2001, and was a relatively obscure outpost in the liquor business. Lee introduced single barrel whiskey as an American answer to the success of Scottish single malts; at the same time, another relatively obscure distillery, Maker’s Mark, was positioning itself as a luxury, small batch product.

A couple of years later, the biggest name in American Whiskey, Jack Daniel’s, cut the proof on its flagship Old No. 7 “Black Label” expression from 90 to 86. The whiskey was cut again in 2002, all the way down to the minimum of 80 proof. In my mind, this was symbolic of what Lynchburg was about at that time: they put an overwhelming emphasis on producing mass market whiskey for a global palate. During a period where other American whiskey distillers were introducing new, distinctive and boldly flavored brands in an effort to reinvent themselves, JD seemed to be moving in the other direction. Their answers to small batch (Gentleman Jack) and single barrel were unremarkable by comparison.

Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Select, on the other hand, has received an upgrade on both the inside and outside. The look of the bottle is much more refined; insofar as what goes into that bottle, improving a single barrel expression is both as simple and as complicated as choosing better (and perhaps fewer) barrels to bottle. Ten years ago, I thought their barrel selection for Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel yielded a product little better than Old No. 7; today, Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Select (94 proof) is a markedly better expression.

Jack Daniels Single Barrel Whiskey
The old look of Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel
(Credit: Brown-Forman)

The Whiskey
A pour of JD SB Select has a light amber/darkened copper look to it. The scent draws a sweet character from candy corn, banana chips and vanilla, accented by toasted oak and a hint of nuts.

Sipping on the whiskey is characteristically mellow, that being a signature of Jack Daniel’s, but with no sacrifice of character. Once again, it’s quite sweet, with brown sugar and vanilla, plus slices of fresh banana. A few slivers of spicy, oak-driven flavor have just enough presence to keep things interesting, but without disturbing the mellow, relaxing experience of the whiskey. I found the finish mild and minty.

Jack Daniel’s doesn’t produce bold and ballsy whiskey. It’s not a characteristic one finds, not even in its cask strength expressions. What they do well down in Lynchburg, Tennessee is produce mellow sipping whiskey. During the last decade, they’ve expanded out of that base, adding more and more character and complexity to that fundamentally mellow foundation. This Single Barrel Select is a sound example of that growth.

I came back around to this expression again in 2024, and found the spicy note more cinnamon than minty for that particular barrel. The banana had that slightly overripe smell on the nose, where some red berries were present as well. But otherwise, I am struck by how similar the two barrels separated by four years actually were.

The Price
A survey of retailers shows how the price on this item has risen these last few years. Whereas it was hovering right around $50 on average in 2020, now that is the floor for the price range. Depending on where you buy it, this could set you back anywhere from $50 to $65.

Liberty Pole Old Monongahela Full Proof Rye Whiskey Review

By Randall H. Borkus Rating: B+ Liberty Pole Spirits is a family-owned and -operated craft distillery started in 2016 by Jim, Ellen, Rob and Kevin Hough. The Houghs are longtime residents of Washington County, Pennsylvania. They caught the distilling bug in the early 2000’s when Jim bought a 10-gallon still and learned the ropes of …

By Randall H. Borkus

Rating: B+

(Credit: Randall H. Borkus)

Liberty Pole Spirits is a family-owned and -operated craft distillery started in 2016 by Jim, Ellen, Rob and Kevin Hough. The Houghs are longtime residents of Washington County, Pennsylvania. They caught the distilling bug in the early 2000’s when Jim bought a 10-gallon still and learned the ropes of making distilled spirits as he contemplated retirement. After visiting various craft distilleries and developing his own respectable whiskey mash bills, Jim convinced Ellen that opening a craft whiskey distillery would a fun retirement endeavor. Rob and Kevin, both mechanical engineers, joined the family business. With Rob and Kevin running production, Ellen created craft cocktails and an incredible visitor experience, and Jim greeting customers and talking whiskey in the tasting room Liberty Pole Spirits became more than a dream. “Liberty Pole” is a registered trademark of Mingo Creek Craft Distillers, LLC.

​The commercial distillery (as opposed to Jim Hough’s hobby) started with a 300-gallon still, expanded to a 600-gallon operation in 2019 and eventually moved to a new facility in 2023, where they tripled production.

The story behind the Liberty Pole started with members of the infamous Mingo Creek Society that would place liberty poles along the roadside and in town centers and then hang Alexander Hamilton’s portrait upside down to protest the 1791 federal excise tax on whiskey. Today, Liberty Pole Spirits continues the production of this rebellious spirit through their authentic Pennsylvania whiskey.

​In authentic Monongahela Rye style, “Old Monongahela Full Proof Rye Whiskey” is made with a high rye mash bill, utilizing a sweet mash distilling process, and using a 108 barrel entry proof. This low barrel entry proof helps prevent the astringency that occurs in high barrel proof whiskeys while extracting delicious flavor notes that tempt the discerning whiskey palate.

The rye mash bill made with 74% rye, (a composite of 61% Pennsylvania grown rye and 13% malted rye) and 13% wheat and 13% malted barley which is distilled in a classic pot still in the Pennsylvania rye whiskey tradition.  The spirit rests in 53-gallon barrels made from Appalachian oak from the West Virginia Great Barrel Company.

The distillery states, “our inaugural release of Old Monongahela Full Proof Rye Whiskey marks a milestone in our journey, showcasing a blend of six barrels ranging from 3.5 to 4.5 years old. Bottled at a proof of 108, mirroring its barrel entry proof [108], this expression captures the true essence of Monongahela Rye.”

The Whiskey
The whiskey’s appearance is a dark amber brown. The nose is full of sweet oak wood notes with hints of Caramel, Vanilla, crushed prunes, and baking spices.  The taste is a full earthy Vanilla mash, sweet dates, cinnamon spice and more sweet oak notes dusted with a hint of mocha.  It reminds me of a polish pudding from my childhood, “budyń waniliowy” which my mom and aunt Jean would make us when I was a kid.  The finish is delightfully warming, medium long with more sweet oak wood, a touch of earthiness and cinnamon sprinkles.

I find this is a must have bottle on my bar, and I was able to have it delivered to my front door.   I am going to have loads of fun with this expression when I host blind rye whiskey tastings with my colleagues.

The Price
Old Monongahela Full Proof Rye Whiskey is available at the distillery and available for shipping at $67 for a 750ml bottle.

Stauning Floor Malted Rye Whiskey Review

By David Levine Rating: B+ It’s hard to believe that Stauning Danish Whisky is almost 20 years old. Founded in 2005 by a group of nine friends, it came online at roughly the same time as the first wave of the new craft movement in the US. In many ways, Stauning represents the entire Nordic/Scandinavian …

By David Levine

Rating: B+

Stauning Floor Malted Rye Whiskey
(Credit: David Levine)

It’s hard to believe that Stauning Danish Whisky is almost 20 years old.

Founded in 2005 by a group of nine friends, it came online at roughly the same time as the first wave of the new craft movement in the US. In many ways, Stauning represents the entire Nordic/Scandinavian region and its new distilling scene. Hundreds of distilleries followed in Stauning’s wake. Flavors of Denmark, Sweden, and Norway (Iceland and Finland, too, depending on who you ask) are suddenly in vogue as the interest in the region’s culinary products and prowess booms around the world.

For Stauning – and these northern European cultures – rye is a specialty. It’s a grain that grows in nearly any soil, a key feature for Vikings and their descendants as they, too, spread around the known world. Barley and wheat might grow. Short of being on a glacier, rye will grow. And so, when building their initial distillery and the gorgeous 24-still successor, Stauning made sure that rye would be a core offering.

American rye drinkers and drinkers of American rye will find this quite different from the rye profiles coming out of Indiana and other famous rye distilling states. There’s no black pepper here, no sharpness you’d expect in a 95/5 or a Monongahela, nor is it sweet like the barely-legal ryes of Maryland and Kentucky. Instead, it is earthy, reminiscent of walking through the very fields from which the rye is harvested. Whether by nature or design, Stauning’s rye feels and tastes closer to the earth, a quality I only find in select American ryes also grown locally to their respective distilleries.

I should note, Stauning makes excellent single malt, but their showcasing of what rye from northern climes tastes like has set a standard. Their products are also surprisingly easy to get, which not many Danish or Scandinavian spirits can say.

This particular rye is floor-malted on-site. I can’t say for sure what that does to the flavors, but it does indicate a level of care for the grain that you can only claim when you’re the one turning the sprouts. Only a dozen or so distilleries do this in the US, all craft, and the few that do it in Scotland are famous for it (Balvenie, for example). Floor-malting rye that’s grown “a bike ride away from the distillery by two local farmers” allows Stauning to rightfully claim Danish terroir, Danish spirit, and Danish rye.

Stauning’s Floor-Malted Rye Whisky is where I entered the world of Scandinavian whisky, and I would argue it’s the best place to do so. The rye is unfamiliar but not enough to scare a newer drinker off, and more experienced whiskyphiles will enjoy their horizons being expanded. I find a strong through-line between their rye and barley spirits, so there’s an easy jump there, and from that point you can bring in other producers like. Spirit of Hven, Eimverk Distillery, and more out-there flavors that are incredibly interesting but might need a steppingstone to reach.

The flip side of this coin is that the rye is relatively simple. It’s far from one note, to be clear; it just feels more like that entry point whisky, one that has enough flavor to stand on its own while being a great canvas for finishing, additional aging, and blending. It’s an easy buy and one sure to inflame interest in Stauning and the larger movement they helped start.

The Whisky
Golden blossom honey in the glass, medium wavy rims and medium-sized droplets encircling. Light and sweet on the nose, hay, farms, and fields without the barnyard funk. Caramel apples heavy on the caramel, almost toffee-like. Candied lemon zest and sugared grapefruit. Cel-Ray soda and fresh lime juice.

Fruity and citrus-forward on the palate with an unfamiliar spice kicking the front of my tongue (I’ve been trying for days to identify it, and it’s not one I have in my kitchen). The farm and haystack notes carry through from the nose. Slightly burnt grain, like a caramel roasted rye or malt towards the back, white grapes and mild astringency, dried orange peel. Mouthfeel is silky and moderately viscous, lighting up the front of my tongue again before settling down to a lighter astringency in the corners of my mouth. The finish reveals just a bit of barnyard funk, like freshly mulched or fertilized fields, with a beautiful fall flavor memory of fallen apples and tree fruits starting to ferment on the ground. Medium length, leans sweet.

Overall: A dominant statement of what Danish rye can be. Reminiscent of farms, fall, and grain, an unfamiliar spice adding intrigue behind the intense flavors. A great standard-bearer for what Scandinavian rye can be and a strong canvas from which to build. At 3+ years old, an easy buy for those looking to expand their palates and try something new.

The Price
A bottle of this Danish rye should cost you $68.99.

Uncle Nearest 777 Anniversary Blend Tennessee Whiskey Review

By Richard Thomas Rating: B+ In June, Uncle Nearest co-founder Fawn Weaver launched her long awaited book about the slave who taught a teenaged Jack Daniel’s how to make whiskey, and whose descendants have worked at making Jack Daniel’s whiskey ever since: Nathan Green. That book, Love and Whiskey, instantly became a best-seller. Uncle Nearest …

By Richard Thomas

Rating: B+

Uncle Nearest 777 Anniversary Blend
(Credit: Uncle Nearest)

In June, Uncle Nearest co-founder Fawn Weaver launched her long awaited book about the slave who taught a teenaged Jack Daniel’s how to make whiskey, and whose descendants have worked at making Jack Daniel’s whiskey ever since: Nathan Green. That book, Love and Whiskey, instantly became a best-seller. Uncle Nearest was founded on the Green legacy; a fifth-generation Green descendant, Victoria Eady Butler, is their Master Blender. So, it only follows that Uncle Nearest has a tie-in to support the release of Love and Whiskey. After all, if Weaver had not been researching that book, Uncle Nearest might never have come into existence. The two projects are very much intertwined.

That support comes in the form of Uncle Nearest 777 Anniversary Blend, the first in a new “Lost Chapter” series. The series is so named because folks who buy the bottle get access to download a “lost chapter” from the book. That will be later extended to those who buy a bottle of Uncle Nearest Single Barrel, after this release runs dry.

This latest release is labeled a Tennessee Whiskey, not a bourbon or a rye, which makes the sourcing behind it especially interesting (while remaining undisclosed). What is in the 7,000 bottles of the consignment is listed as seven years old and bottled at cask strength (my sample was a hair over 120 proof), but keep in mind that Tennessee Whiskey has had a legal mandate since 2013. That means the sourcing behind this must not just come from Tennessee, but also must use the Lincoln County Process (unless it is Prichard’s). Keep in mind the standard Uncle Nearest releases are all bourbon or rye. The list of suspects for where the liquid came from is therefore quite short and does not include any of the usual suspects.

The Whiskey
My pour of Uncle Nearest 777 had a clear, middle amber look to it. The whiskey was just over 120 proof, so of course I put a splash of water in. I found the nose bright orange zest and vanilla, coming hand in hand with a current of cinnamon graham cracker. Further nosing brought out a curiously beefy note, like a trace of what emanates from my kitchen when I am doing a tenderloin steak. The palate hangs onto many of those elements, but turning a touch woody and peppery with one hand, while reaching out to some earthy cocoa with the other. I believe it is that beefy note I picked up in the scent that turned earthy on the palate. The finish ran mildly woody and peppery.

The peppery note is the truly peculiar part, as Tennessee Whiskey is mostly associated with the mellow George Dickel and the even mellower Jack Daniel’s. As enjoyable as the whiskey was, I am having more fun wracking my brain about the sourcing.

The Price
A bottle of Uncle Nearest 777 will set out back $139.

Old Forester Birthday Bourbon Review (2024)

By Richard Thomas Rating: A- In some ways, the bourbon calendar is more predictable than the real passage of the seasons, especially here in Kentucky and in the era of climate change. Today it is dry and quite pleasant outside, but I have no idea if the next round of storms will bring with it …

By Richard Thomas

Rating: A-

Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2024
(Credit: Brown-Forman)

In some ways, the bourbon calendar is more predictable than the real passage of the seasons, especially here in Kentucky and in the era of climate change. Today it is dry and quite pleasant outside, but I have no idea if the next round of storms will bring with it a return to steamy, late summer weather. Meanwhile, I know for certain the autumnal season of red hot American whiskey releases is around the corner, because Old Forester has dropped the year’s Birthday Bourbon.

The 2024 Old Forester Birthday Bourbon is already unique in that it was bottled at 107 proof, which is the strongest ever bottling for the expression. The release was also attended by a sweepstakes, which saw 1,000 lucky contestants bypass the usual trouble of bottle hunting (or expense of paying market value). They won the right to go to the Old Forester Distillery on Louisville’s Whiskey Row and buy a bottle at MSRP. Past that, the tale of this year’s tribute to George Garvin Brown is typical. Master Distiller Emeritus Chris Morris and Master Taster Melissa Rift hand-selected 209 barrels for the release, with all those bottles being 12 years or older. That is part for the course for this expression, which is routinely middle aged.

The Bourbon
The pour took a dulled, middle amber look in the glass, and I could tell right away that it was borderline on whether water should be added. I frankly find the fever for drinking Hazmat whiskeys neat baffling (as concentrate bottles, they’re great, but drinking something you could run your weed whacker on neat?), but 107 proof is a spot where maybe water is needed and maybe it isn’t. As I left the glass on the table to take some air, I detected a hint of heat. Subsequent nosing showed it stayed there, but a hint of heat is not problematic. So, no water added to this bourbon.

The nose was spice-forward, with the initial impression being very gingerbread before candy corn and caramel. Further nosing developed that spicy current on the front into cloves, ginger and charred oak, with the sweet side remaining quite rooted in candy corn and caramel, with a little green apple thrown in. Most interesting is the trademark Old Forester banana note is gone.

That spicy current morphs into a herbaceous spiciness on the palate. The ginger note continues, but now it is tied to spearmint. That sits atop a syrupy , thick bourbon sweetness of molasses, vanilla and pipe tobacco. The finish ran woody with an almost meaty undertone, before turning woody and spicy to fade away with.

The Price
The official price for this year’s Birthday Bourbon is $200.

Del Bac Classic Bottled in Bond Whiskey Review

By Richard Thomas Rating: B+ Although Whiskey del Bac (aka Hamilton Distillers, although they don’t seem to use that name so much anymore) has had their Arizona-style American malt whiskey on the market for almost a decade now, they only just released their first bottled in bond this year. My guess is that this was …

By Richard Thomas

Rating: B+

Whiskey Del Bac Classic Bottled in Bond
(Credit: Hamilton Distillers)

Although Whiskey del Bac (aka Hamilton Distillers, although they don’t seem to use that name so much anymore) has had their Arizona-style American malt whiskey on the market for almost a decade now, they only just released their first bottled in bond this year. My guess is that this was because they continued to tweak and improve it from their first unveiling. Knowing a little something about whiskey maturation in the Southwest, I’m thinking the learning curve on how to keep barrels for the four years-plus needed to do a bonded whiskey was part of it as well. Stephen Paul, co-founder of Whiskey del Bac, said that he had been wanting to do a bonded whiskey for a long time, but wanted to master their malt whiskey style before embarking on such a project.

The whiskey built on the current version of Whiskey del Bac Classic. It was laid down in 2020 by their previous Master Distiller, Veronica Townsend, in 53 gallon American Standard Barrels as part of an experiment in moving the size of their barrels upward. In keeping with the Bottled in Bond Act, the whiskey is a minimum of four years old, all comes from a single distilling season/year; and is bottled at 100 proof.

The Whiskey
My pour hit the glass bronzed. Like del Bac Classic, it’s nose evoked this meeting point of Scotch and American candy currents, with strong caramel and butterscotch in the nose. Underneath that was a hint of musty hay, like the bale that sat in the corner of the loft, dry but forgotten.

Sipping revealed a thick, but silky texture to the liquid, and flipped the script to a certain extent on the nose. That musty undertone came forward and developed into an oakier, spicier character, bringing that caramel, honey and butterscotch sweet side into balance. Further sipping brought out a modest note of nectarine. The finish ran with the woody, spicy aspect, but that faded speedily and left a sweet, damp tobacco note to linger on.

Overall, this is a solid step forward for American malts, craft whiskey in the Southwest and Whiskey del Bac. I find myself wishing not just for more of this item, but also a bonded version of their mesquite-smoked malt.

The Price
Only 500 bottles of this were made, which is quite normal for a bonded whiskey coming from a small distiller, but some are still available for $120.

Boann Single Pot Still P.X. Cask Irish Whiskey Review

By Alex Southgate Rating: A I’m a firm believer in not having too much of a good thing. That being said, it’s nice to be able to get two expressions from the same distillery in one go. This is great for a number of, but the main one is that it gives us a good …

By Alex Southgate

Rating: A

Boann Single Pot Still PX Cask
(Credit: Boann Distillery)

I’m a firm believer in not having too much of a good thing. That being said, it’s nice to be able to get two expressions from the same distillery in one go. This is great for a number of, but the main one is that it gives us a good idea of the variety of whiskey that is being brought to the market. So after my previous acquaintance with Ireland’s Boann recently, I was eager to see whether I liked their triple distilled P.X. cask expression just as much. I have to say that after that last review, I had high hopes.

The Boann Single Pot Still triple Distilled P.X. Cask Irish Whiskey we’re trying today was initially matured in Oloroso Sherry hogsheads from Bodegas Garvey of Jerez de la Frontera, Spain. These American Oak hogsheads were chosen alongside George Espie and Ventura Nunez from the famed cooperage in Jerez. These were filled with a mixed mash bill, single pot distillate which included locally sourced malted and un-malted barley, oats and rye.

PX butts which had been in the PX Solera system for 60 years were sourced for the finishing. These butts came from Malaga and a portion of them were made exclusively of chestnut, which is a very rare variety of wood when it comes to maturing whiskey in Ireland. Mind you, after six decades in use for making Sherry, it is open to question just how much influence the chestnut itself has. The Oloroso-aged Single Pot Still was finished in these vintage Solera PX casks to create a product that is truly special and decadent. The cask strength of this Irish whiskey is 47%.

The Whiskey
The Boann PX Cask expression struck me the moment it hit the glass. The whiskey is a deep honey in hue but aside from the appealing color what really jumped out at me was the scent. The nose from this
whiskey was apparent immediately on the pour and filled the air with delicious aromas. I hadn’t placed the glass anywhere near my nose and I already couldn’t wait to see what this whiskey had in store.

The nose begins with creamy toffee notes that are rich in buttery caramel. These softer notes deepen into sticky molasses which is paired with juicy raisins. These juicy, fruity tones then lift for a finish of leather.

To the taste we begin with a gooey honey sweetness that is cut beautifully with a background of white pepper. These flavors shift into decadent dark chocolate. This is beautifully rich and long lasting on the palate. The savoury peppery notes return for the finish and carry to the end.

This is a fabulous whiskey. I really enjoy expressions that aren’t trying to be too many different things at once. Too often we end up with a multitude of flavors that, while working well on their own become confused when mixed together. Everything in the P.X. cask rendition from Boann has a place and does its job perfectly.

I think I mentioned in my last review that the Sherry cask expression was clever because it left the palate clear so you could keep going back for more. I think it’s important to note this again. In that instance mint was being used to do this, in this case its pepper. Both of these flavors have the desired effect in being an excellent carry so that you can keep going back for more.

All in all this is a very tasty tipple and not only am I going to be adding this bottle to my own collection but I think Boann, a company that was completely new to me, is going to be one that I’ll be exploring a lot more in the future.

The Price
The Boann Single Pot PX Cask Irish Whiskey is coming it at €69.95, which is roughly £59 for those of us in the UK and $79 in the US.

Knob Creek Bourbon x Rye Review

By Richard Thomas Rating: B+ Hybrids, or blends of two or more types of whiskeys, have been an interesting and rewarding niche ever since Wild Turkey introduced their now defunct hybrid expression more than a decade ago. Wild Turkey Forgiven was supposedly based on a batching accident, became something of a fan favorite, and consisted …

By Richard Thomas

Rating: B+

Knob Creek Bourbon X Rye
(Credit: Beam Suntory)

Hybrids, or blends of two or more types of whiskeys, have been an interesting and rewarding niche ever since Wild Turkey introduced their now defunct hybrid expression more than a decade ago. Wild Turkey Forgiven was supposedly based on a batching accident, became something of a fan favorite, and consisted of an approximately 3/4 bourbon, 1/4 rye blend. Utah’s High West has also had its noted hybrids, such as Bourye, while Virginia Distilling Company (VDCo) began by crafting hybrids of imported Scottish malts with their then young in-house malts. VDCo continues that practice with their limited edition Cask Selections.

Now Jim Beam has joined the hybrid party, using their Knob Creek brand to introduce Knob Creek Bourbon X Rye. That makes sense, given that Knob Creek is known for both its bourbon and rye. Beam chose to buck the Wild Turkey model and go with a rye-forward blend of 70% rye whiskey and 30% bourbon, and in both cases they are using the literal standards for the brand: nine year old bourbon, same as Knob Creek Small Batch; and seven year old rye, same as Knob Creek Rye. Given the balance, perhaps the order should be Rye X Bourbon, but regardless another feature of Knob Creek’s brand continues here: it’s ballsy, bottled at 113 proof.

The Whiskey
With such a rye-forward hybrid, I wasn’t surprised when my pour of Knob Creek Bourbon X Rye took a light amber coloring, since rye whiskey often leans out of amber and into copper and bronze. Where the weight of the blend sat appeared in the nose as well, as despite Beam’s rye whiskey being a Kentucky style “barely” rye (i.e. scarcely more than the required 51% rye content), it lead with its spicy aspect of cinnamon, clove and a vaguely herbal note, followed by brown sugar and vanilla, plus some dried cherries and orange zest.

The flavor flipped the script, leading with the sweet side of brown sugar and caramel. This was covered by a rising layer of spice which turns from baking spices to musty, woody and peppery by the time the sweetness is subsumed. The finish, however, jinks back to balance and runs like cinnamon toast.

Although this Knob Creek hybrid is not actually superior to either of its constituent expressions, it comes out quite different and equal in quality to either. For diehard Knob Creek or Jim Beam fans, it is a must-buy, just as trying to replicate the blend yourself is a must-try experiment.

The Price
Officially, this item is priced at $45. Because it’s Knob Creek, you will probably be able to snag it at or near that price too.

Hatozaki Omakase Rye Finished in Mizunara Casks Review (3rd Edition)

By David Levine Rating: B Mizunara – just the word makes whisky lovers’ ears perk up and their wallets empty. This Japanese oak species is native to Hokkaido, Japan’s northernmost island, belying its scientific name of Quercus mongolica (though some sources label it as crispula, a variant of mongolica). An average new, 53 gallon American …

By David Levine

Rating: B

Hatozaki Omakase Mizunara Finished Rye Whiskey
(Credit: Akashi Brewery)

Mizunara – just the word makes whisky lovers’ ears perk up and their wallets empty. This Japanese oak species is native to Hokkaido, Japan’s northernmost island, belying its scientific name of Quercus mongolica (though some sources label it as crispula, a variant of mongolica).

An average new, 53 gallon American oak cask is a few hundred dollars, with re-use barrels being turned for as little as $50-$100 each. Mizunara, by comparison, averages upwards of $3,000-$5,000 for a new cask and…well, not that much less for a used one. It’s expensive, rare, and extremely hard to work with. Mizunara is knotty, making it both difficult to cut stave-quality slices and leading to a notorious propensity to leak. It’s also tight-grained and takes upwards of 200 years to mature, 2.5x as long as the average barrel-quality American oak.

To be fair, it does impart a flavor profile unmatched by American, French, and other various European oak species with which we’re more familiar. If we put aside the cost and just look at the flavor, this is a fascinating pairing of American rye and Japanese oak. I was most surprised by the lack of comparative products. For some reason, I had been under the assumption that more brands had tried the pairing – perhaps Barrell or another blending house or NDP, but no. Thus this is a rarer combo than I went in believing.

My guess is that the cost alone scared most away from using it with anything other than bourbon, which is still much more likely to sell on a 1:1 basis than rye. It’s a real shame – I find myself enjoying this pour more and more as I sip it, despite it taking a bit of time to open.

If there were one thing I want to chirp about, it’s something that’s not Hatozaki’s fault. By purchasing totes of rye and blending them in Japan then finishing in the mizunara, to me it takes away from the “American”-ness of the product. On its face that sounds stupid, I know, but hear me out. For some reason that I cannot fully explain, if Hatozaki had done this same process in the US I’d have no such issue.

Just possibly, it’s because neither the rye nor the mizunara are unique to Hatozaki, so in a way there’s nothing specifically Hatozaki about this. Yes, they blend and finish at their Kaikyō, and they (I’m guessing) pick the casks, so there is skill involved.

Clearly I’m conflicted on this, and I’ll have to think about it a lot more to really understand why I’m having such a problem reconciling what is an objectively very good product and my issues with its provenance. In fairness to this product, then, I will rate it only on the pour’s merits.

The Whiskey
In a Glencairn, looks like assam black tea, with medium sloughing rims, medium legs and tiny drops. The nose is quite aromatic, both rye herbal sweetness and mizunara perfume hitting right away. Though listed at “at least” 51% rye, I’d guess the final blend was closer to 60-70%. Unlit incense sticks, potentially sandalwood, some tarragon and a hint of ripe banana.

The palate is a bonanza of flavor, sweet-ish herbs, the barest astringency with maple sugar and patchouli. Expired clove and vanilla round out the back gently. Drinks at or slightly above proof. Mouthfeel is light but syrupy, pepper spice on the tip of my tongue with the incense catching fire. Somewhat coating and covers the whole tongue. Brings out the rye’s darker side. The finish showcases a clearer sandalwood flavor, with the mizunara taking charge. A light red and white fruit salad entering late to add an extra dimension to this. Medium length with a quick ending.

Overall: hits all the notes you expect from a rye finished in mizunara, so full marks for intentionality. At $95, this won’t break the bank, especially for a bottle involving mizunara and cross-globe moving of spirits. Being a sourced rye finished in mizunara, though, I can’t help but wonder if there should be more of a story or another element of this to make it more experiential.

The Price
As mentioned previously, this is a $95 for a 750 ml bottle. The production run for this 3rd edition is about 3,000 bottles.

Boann Single Pot Still Marsala Cask Irish Whiskey Review

By Alex Southgate Rating: A I’ve always been a huge fan of Irish Whiskeys. I’m painting with a very broad brush here, but I tend to find them smoother than many Scotch expressions. That may be because I am not a fan of overtly peaty flavors, so I find that a lot of Irish Whiskeys …

By Alex Southgate

Rating: A

Boann Marsala Cask Single Pot Still Whiskey
(Credit: Boann Distillery)

I’ve always been a huge fan of Irish Whiskeys. I’m painting with a very broad brush here, but I tend to find them smoother than many Scotch expressions. That may be because I am not a fan of overtly peaty flavors, so I find that a lot of Irish Whiskeys suit my palate better. This being said, I was excited to take a metaphorical trip over the Irish Sea for today’s review: to Drogheda and the Boann Distillery, with their Single Pot Still Marsala Cask Whiskey, and I can’t wait to see what it brings.

Boann is a family run company founded by Patrick and Mary Cooney and their family; Sally-Anne, Celestine, Peter, Patrick and James. They bring a combined 40 years of experience in the Irish drinks industry, having built the Gleeson Group from a small, independent, bottler to a company bringing in an impressing €300 million per year. With this in mind we can safely say they know what they’re talking about with respect to the creation of premium whiskey.

The Marsala Cask expression was initially matured in ex-Kentucky bourbon barrels from Brown-Forman (so either Old Forester or Woodford Reserve) with a heavy charring. These casks were filled with a mixed mash bill Single Pot distillate which included locally grown, malted and un-malted barley, oats and rye. The whiskey was then finished in Marsala Butts made from French Oak, sourced from the famous Marsala house Cantine de Vinci. This Marsala Cask expression is coming out at a cask strength of 47% ABV.

The Whiskey
The Boann Marsala Single Pot Still is a beautifully clear, soft honey to the eye. This is a very light whiskey, leaving only faint legs on the pour and barely clinging to the sides of the glass. The enticing scent of this expression greeted me before I raised the glass to my nose and this coupled with the appealing visuals made for something I couldn’t wait to taste.

The nose is immediately thick with honey. Sweet notes that are paired with juicy raisins are the first aromas to greet you. These honey notes deepen and are met with toasted orange backed by just a hint of char.

The first thing that I notice when tasking this expression is a sweet and sour citrus punch coming from a mix of candied orange and lemon peel. These punchy notes lift to reveal the freshness of peppermint, something that carries on the palate and remains to the finish. The finish is one of soft spices with an undercurrent of oak.

The Boann Single Pot Marsala expression was a really interesting experience for me. The prevalence of mint as one of the main flavours of this whiskey was something that was new to me and a very pleasant surprise. This whiskey is very fresh and clean on the palate and as such is one that you can keep going back to. With this being said, this is the sort of whiskey that you wouldn’t get tired of after a glass or two and this is something that, for me, earns it a lot of points.

The other thing that I think is important to note is that this isn’t an expensive whiskey in the grand scheme of things. I’ll come to the price in a moment but this is a very affordable tipple and as such on that could, (and will,) be finding a permanent home in my liquor cabinet. This is definitely one that I think I’ll be recommending to my friends and a whiskey that I would absolutely try if you are able.

The Price
The Boann Single Pot Marsala whiskey is coming in at €69.95 or roughly £60 for those of us here in England.